Some reflections on assessment



I recently embarked on a learning journey on assessment in mathematics for my TLLP project. The goal of our project is to create a school-wide approach to assessment with a focus on mathematics.

It has been very interesting to collect data and observe and listen to my colleagues about assessment. Many concerns that they have I also have had for many years. These questions centered mainly around using learning goals successfully and around turning our conversations and observations into quantitative data to give to parents.

Recently, we had our assessment coordinator Kristen Clarke come in a start the conversation going. During this time we talked about what learning goals are, the board’s pedagogical model and then how we as teachers have been assessing. It was great to converse with my colleagues and hear what they had to say.

As I mentioned before the conversations centered around using our observations and conversations as marks. This got me thinking. I think we need to give ourselves the permission to use conversations and observations. I think that for the longest time we have seen assessment as evaluation only and that evaluation met some sort of quantitative number. But is that really true? Does evaluation have to be a quantitative value or is a comment just as evaluative as a mark?

I think as educators we have to get more use to using our comments and observations as proof that children are meeting standards. That when truth be told they hold more meat than a mark ever would. In Ontario, we have an assessment document called growing success. Personally, I think this is an amazing resource that discusses our three focus points for evaluation is through products, observations, and conversations. If you look at the mathematics this means observations and conversations take a 66.6666% of evaluation and that product is just 33.33%. It means that our observations and conversations we have with students mean more than what they produce on paper.

So the question that I have is, why are we so invested in the mark? Or feel that observations and conversations are not tangible enough for us to hang our hats on?

For me, there is more to assessment than evaluation and I think we as educators need to think more about that thought. In addition, assessment needs to be more than just giving students feedback. It needs to be embedded into everything that we do. It needs to be responsive and it needs to be reflective. As a school-wide approach, it is important that we have honest conversations about the importance of assessment and what role it plays in our school community. I know that my journey has just begun so stay tuned as we as a school and me personally delve more into our learning.

I would also love to hear your thinking about my questions or just your thoughts about assessment.


Author: MrSoClassroom

I am a grade school Teacher, promoting creativity and exploration in all of my students. My classroom is always in a state of Inquiry.

3 thoughts on “Some reflections on assessment”

  1. Excellent questions Jonathan!

    I sometimes wonder if the marks we put on the report cards mean that they are successful learners or our pre-conceived idea of where the students are on their track to eventually go to a university. One is useful no matter where you are headed, the other only applies to about one third of our students. [Give or take depending on the SES of the school.]


    1. That is one of my problems with marks. If it’s the later then are we serving everyone? Is there a better way of admitting to university? Or can we still have letter grades for reports but only for that?


  2. I really like the outer ring of the assessment planning framework in the picture. I’ve been playing around with and thinking a lot about how we might assess creativity and curiosity in an assessment for learning context so that we might encourage students to be as creative and curious as they can be. It might not be possible. It might also be one of those things that if you try to assess it, it might disappear. I do feel that a culture of risk-taking and choice would be beneficial.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s